To what extent can situation ethics be accurately described as a religious ethical theory

If, on the other hand, sociology be regarded as the aggregate of the sciences which have reference to the social life of man, it is not a single science but a complexus of sciences ; and among these, so far as the natural order is concerned, ethics has the first claim.

Virtue Ethics

It is possible that the baby could grow up to be a serial killer and the old man could have his most important years ahead of him. The purpose of these societies is declared to be "the improvement of the moral life of the members of the societies and of the community to which they belong, without any regard to theological or philosophical opinions".

The language associated with this school uses the terms "right" and "wrong" to evaluate actions. The Creator might, of course, dispense for a time from the unity and indissolubility of the marriage tie; for, though the perfection of the married state demands these qualities, they are not of absolute necessity; the principal end of marriage may be attained to a certain degree without them.

For his ideal State he proposed the community of goods and of wives and the public education of children. They argue that, by contrast, under rule utilitarianism injustices against minorities would not be encouraged because: He is, then, the ultimate end of all things, they are created for His sake, not, indeed, that he can derive any benefit from them, which would be repugnant to an infinitely perfect being, but for His glory.

Many buttons are pushed so that the overall condition is improved and not to the benefit of any particular faction. Zygmunt Bauman says postmodernity is best described as modernity without illusion, the illusion being the belief that humanity can be repaired by some ethic principle.

Should his researches lead to conclusions out of harmony with faithhe is to take it for granted that some error has crept into his deductions, just as the mathematician whose calculations openly contradict the facts of experience must be satisfied that his demonstration is at fault.

In a sense, the State is man writ large, and its function is to train its citizens in virtue. This faithhowever, is not the acceptance of truth on the strength of external authority, but rather consists in certain appreciative judgments, i.

Focusing on goods, one looks at the health of the whole and of each part of the whole. Such theorists find narrative or, following Nietzsche and Foucault, genealogy to be a helpful tool for understanding ethics because narrative is always about particular lived experiences in all their complexity rather than the assignment of an idea or norm to separate and individual actions.

According to the cultural relativist, the attempt to evaluate the moral beliefs of one's own culture is bound to fail because: A modern version of rule-consequentialism, which is in many respects sensitive to the insights of virtue.

Melanchthonin his "Elementa philosophiae moralis", still clung to the Aristotelean philosophy; so, too, did Hugo Grotius, in his work, "De jure belli et pacis".

Biologically, what is good for an organism is what helps it survive and thrive, what nourishes it. Pleasure, for example, appears to not be good without qualification, because when people take pleasure in watching someone suffer, they make the situation ethically worse. The Cynics, Antisthenes B.

All evil arises from ignoranceand the virtues are one and all but so many kinds of prudence. Weiss, Renninger, Lehmen, Willems, V.


By what right indeed can we demand that we should be treated in one fashion, reserving it to ourselves to treat others in a fashion entirely different. According to him, goodness was originaly identified with nobility and gentility of rank.

The PSDA obligates healthcare providers to ensure that patients are informed of their legal rights, under individual state law, to make decisions about their own healthcare, as well as to create an advance directive for themselves.

Epicurus proposes that, even though decision-making should be based on the pursuit of pleasure, not all pleasures ought to be pursued equally, because: Thus, we should prioritize social reform over attempts to account for consequences, individual virtue or duty although these may be worthwhile attempts, if social reform is provided for.

For Utilitarians, no action is intrinsically right or wrong. Agent-based Virtue Ethics", Utilitas, vol. In case it is God's good pleasure to reveal a supernatural religion and to determine in detail the manner and means of our worship of Him, man is bound by the natural law to accept this revelation in a spirit of faith.

Chatto and Windus, We do not wish to be ruled. The most well-known provision of the act is its standards regarding the electronic exchange of sensitive, private health information.

Rival accounts have tried to incorporate the benefits of virtue ethics and develop in ways that will allow them to respond to the challenged raised by virtue ethics.

Finally, the State has to exercise important economical functions. The latter elect from their number representatives who frame their laws and administer the affairs of government in their name.

And how can any one manage to believe himself an anarchist unless he practices it. They cannot be proven false because: Recourse was again had to the illustrius past of Catholicismwhile, at the same time, modern ethical systems gave occasion to a thorough investigation and verification of principles of the moral order.

It is not just that the virtues lead to the good life e. It can be argued that providing there is a large enough group of people using one person or a small group of people as a means rather than ends in themselves would have to be considered morally permissible on the grounds of the greatest happiness for the greatest number.

The Theory of Situation Ethics

Intellectual superiority is above and beyond good and evil as understood in the traditional sense. Or, at least, may not society the State abolish private ownership and assume possession and control of all material goods either wholly or in part, in order to thus distribute among the members of the community the products of their joint industry.

We can cast the dilemma mentioned earlier entirely in terms of right and wrong instead of Right vs. PHIL. CHAPTER 5. STUDY. PLAY. FALSE. TRUE. A problem that the text raised with the divine command theory of ethics is that A) no intelligent person believes in God. B)many morally abhorrent actions have been defended on the basis of God's commands.

By definition no one can be both an ethical egoist and a hedonist. C) Some ethical. Chapter Ethics. STUDY. Code of ethical mores b. Code of ethics c. Code of social values d.

Ethics and Law in Occupational Therapy Practice

Statutory ethics. b. Who decides what constitutes an emergency? a. EMT b. Paramedic When the order is against your religious beliefs b. When the order is contraindicated for the patient c. When the order is not in the doctor's best interests. The words "moral" and "ethics" (and cognates) are often used interchangeably.

However, it is useful to make the following distinction: Morality is the system through which we determine right and wrong conduct -- i.e., the guide to good or right conduct.

Ethics is the philosophical study of Morality. What, then, is a moral theory? Anthropology, moreover, is necessarily presupposed by ethics. No rules can be prescribed for man's actions, unless his nature is clearly understood.

so too the Socialists favour the theory of evolution from their ethical viewpoint; In view of the chaos of opinions and systems just described, it need not surprise us that, as regards. Virtue Ethics. Virtue ethics is a broad term for theories that emphasize the role of character and virtue in moral philosophy rather than either doing one’s duty or acting in order to bring about good consequences.

A virtue ethicist is likely to give you this kind of moral advice: “Act as a virtuous person would act in your situation.”. Home > A Level and IB > Religious Studies > The Theory of Situation Ethics.

The Theory of Situation Ethics.

/ 5. Hide Show resource information. Religious Studies; Fullscreen. Three kinds of ethical theory; Fletcher says that there are essentially three main ways of making moral decisions. Religious Studies- Situation Ethics.

To what extent can situation ethics be accurately described as a religious ethical theory
Rated 3/5 based on 69 review
The Theory of Situation Ethics - Revision Notes in A Level and IB Religious Studies